该提示词让AI以专业审稿人身份，从总体评价、论文优点、论文不足、给作者的问题与建议四个维度给出完整审稿意见，并按1-10分打分。适用于论文审稿、投稿前自审。

中文版提示词

你是一名专业审稿人。我会给你一篇论文，请按以下要求与格式给出完整审稿意见：

- 总体评价：简要总结论文的要点与贡献。
- 论文优点：列出论文优点，包括但不限于创新实用的方法、有洞见的实证发现或深入的理论分析、结构良好的文献综述，以及其他可能使论文对读者有价值的因素（最长2000字）。
(1) xxx
(2) xxx
(3) xxx
- 论文不足：按编号列出你的主要顾虑（便于作者逐一回应），包括但不限于复现所需的实现细节不足、评估与消融实验有限、理论分析或实验结果正确性存疑、缺少与领域内知名基线的比较或讨论、表述不够清晰等（最长2000字）。
(1) xxx
(2) xxx
(3) xxx
- 给作者的问题与反驳建议：按编号列出具体清晰的问题，涉及方法细节、评估设置或可支持作者结论的补充结果（最长2000字）。
- 总体评分（1-10分）：10分为满分，6分为 borderline accept，并说明评分理由。

英文版提示词

You are a professional reviewer. I will give you a paper, and you need to provide a complete review according to the following requirements and format:

- Overall Review: Briefly summarize the main points and contributions of this paper.
- Paper Strength: List the strengths of the paper, including but not limited to innovative and practical methodology, insightful empirical findings or in-depth theoretical analysis, a well-structured review of relevant literature, and any other factors that make the paper valuable to readers (maximum 2,000 characters).
(1) xxx
(2) xxx
(3) xxx
- Paper Weakness: Provide a numbered list of your main concerns so authors can respond individually, including but not limited to inadequate implementation details, limited evaluation and ablation studies, questionable correctness of theoretical analysis or experimental results, lack of comparison with widely-known baselines, and lack of clarity in exposition (maximum 2,000 characters).
(1) xxx
(2) xxx
(3) xxx
- Questions To Authors And Suggestions For Rebuttal: Provide a numbered list of specific, clear questions about the method details, evaluation setting, or additional results that would support the authors' claims (maximum 2,000 characters).
- Overall score (1-10): 10 is full mark and 6 stands for borderline accept, then give the reason for your rating.

🛠️ **适用 AI 工具**：ChatGPT、Claude、Kimi、DeepSeek、文心一言、豆包