以审稿人视角列出论文6条缺点,从创新意义、与先前工作对比、实验设计、写作与组织结构等方面分析,要求英文输出、语言中立简洁,并尽量指明具体位置,适合投稿前自查。
中文版提示词
帮我列出这篇论文的缺点。你可以从以下方面考虑内容: 1. 说明这篇工作在本领域创新意义的不足,以及未来可能面临的不足。 2. 对比之前的工作,说明这篇论文的不足之处与可改进之处。 3. 说明这篇工作在实验上的不足,实验设计是否有说服力,是否需要补充额外实验。 4. 根据我发给你的「review」文件,说明这篇文章在写作、组织结构、画图等其他方面的不足;若存在不足,请具体指出在论文的哪个位置。 最终输出的语言要求: 1. 用英文回复我。 2. 分6个缺点回答。 3. 语言中立,不要夸它好;语言简短,不输出无意义的修饰词或额外词汇。 4. 如可能,请指出某缺点在论文的具体位置。 5. 不要与优点的观点发生冲突。 6. 充分考虑我给你提出的上述方面。 7. 可模仿以下风格生成论文缺点,文字尽量简洁: 【There are also some weak points to be improved: W1: discussion of important xxx are not sufficient. W2: detailed explanations should be provided to enhance xxx. W3: xxx. W4: xxx. W5: xxx. W6: xxx.】
英文版提示词
Help me list the weaknesses of this paper. You may consider the following aspects: 1. Explain the insufficient novelty of this work in the field and the shortcomings it may face in the future. 2. Compare with prior work and explain the paper's weaknesses and areas for improvement. 3. Explain the experimental shortcomings of this work, whether the experimental design is convincing, and whether additional experiments are needed. 4. Based on the "review" file I send you, explain the paper's weaknesses in writing, organization, figures, and other aspects; if such weaknesses exist, point out specifically where in the paper they are. Requirements for the final output language: 1. Reply in English. 2. Answer with six weaknesses. 3. Use neutral language, do not praise it; keep the language brief, without meaningless modifiers or extra words. 4. If possible, point out the specific location in the paper of each weakness. 5. Do not conflict with any points about the paper's strengths. 6. Fully consider the aspects I listed above. 7. You may follow this style to generate the paper's weaknesses, keeping the wording as concise as possible: 【There are also some weak points to be improved: W1: discussion of important xxx are not sufficient. W2: detailed explanations should be provided to enhance xxx. W3: xxx. W4: xxx. W5: xxx. W6: xxx.】

◯ 评论 0